Skip to content
demergertax
Talk to us

Separating property · Family Investment Company · £3m

Demerging a £3m London building into a Family Investment Company

How a London family travel agency moved its £3m building into a new company with a capital reduction demerger, with no capital gains tax, corporation tax or SDLT.

At a glance

  • Client: a family travel agency in London, trading since 1980, owned by three siblings holding 70%, 20% and 10%
  • The asset: the company's own building, bought for around £200,000 and now worth around £3m
  • What we did: a capital reduction demerger, with the demerged company then set up as the family's Family Investment Company
  • Tax on the way: no capital gains tax, no corporation tax on the gain and no SDLT on the demerger
  • Saving: over £800,000, with the property's base cost reflecting its current value of around £3m
  • Timescale: three months from instruction to completion, including HMRC clearances and all the legal work

The client

A family travel agency in London, trading successfully since 1980. Decades ago, the company bought the building it trades from for around £200,000. Today that building is worth around £3m.

The company is owned by three siblings, with 70%, 20% and 10%. The eldest sister holds the largest share and manages the family's affairs for everyone.

What the family wanted

  • Succession. The building is a key part of the family's wealth from one generation to the next. They wanted it held for the family over the long term, including the siblings' children.
  • Flexibility on the business. The family may sell the trading business in future. Keeping the property inside the trading company would complicate that sale and expose the building to trading risk.
  • Fairness. With three siblings holding different stakes and the next generation coming through, the structure had to be fair to everyone and clear about who decides what.

The challenge

Taking the building out of the company the ordinary way would have been expensive.

  • Corporation tax on the gain. Moving a building worth around £3m that cost around £200,000 would create a gain of around £2.8m in the company. At 25%, that is around £700,000 of corporation tax.
  • SDLT. A transfer of the property to another company would ordinarily trigger stamp duty land tax on its market value, adding a further six-figure cost.
  • Tax on the family. Getting the property, or its value, out to the siblings personally would bring further tax on top.

Together, the corporation tax on the gain and the SDLT came to well over £800,000, before any personal tax.

What we did

  • Carried out a capital reduction demerger. The building was separated from the trading company into a new company owned by the family, in the same proportions as the trading company. A capital reduction demerger is a reconstruction for tax purposes, so with the right reliefs and HMRC clearance in place there was no capital gains tax for the siblings, no corporation tax on the gain in the company and no SDLT.
  • Fixed the base cost. We structured the steps so that the property's base cost in the new company reflects its current value of around £3m, rather than the original £200,000. If the family sold the building tomorrow, there would be no capital gains to pay on the growth to date. The anti-avoidance rules were dealt with in the HMRC clearance application before any step was taken.
  • Set up the Family Investment Company. The demerged company became the family's Family Investment Company. The share structure brings in the three siblings and their children, and the eldest sister holds the voting control.
  • Applied for HMRC clearance first, then took the legal steps to the cleared plan. The legal documents and Companies House filings were prepared to the cleared step plan, and we checked each one against it.

The outcome

  • The building now sits in the family's own company, separate from the trading business and its risks.
  • The trading business carries on exactly as before, and is cleaner to sell if the family decides to.
  • No capital gains tax, no corporation tax on the gain and no SDLT on the demerger: a saving of over £800,000.
  • The property's base cost reflects its current value of around £3m.
  • The next generation is involved, with control clearly held and the structure fair to all three branches of the family.
  • Three months from instruction to completion.

What happens next

  • Further properties. The family owns other properties, which are being transferred directly into the Family Investment Company. Some have only a small gain, so the SDLT cost on those transfers is manageable.
  • Inheritance tax. A family trust has been set up to move value out of the siblings' estates over time. We are working through that stage now.

Could this work for you?

If your trading company owns its building, or other property, and you are thinking about succession, a future sale or protecting the property from trading risk, a capital reduction demerger is worth exploring. The order of the steps, the reliefs, the anti-avoidance rules and the HMRC clearance all need to be right.

Figures are rounded. This case study describes one family's circumstances. Every case depends on its own facts and on the law at the time, and nothing here is a guarantee of a tax outcome.

BEFOREShareholdersThe companyTradePropertyAFTERShareholdersHoldConewNewConewTradeCoPropCo
  1. 1Insert a new holding company by share-for-share exchange.
  2. 2The holding company reduces its share capital, backed by a solvency statement.
  3. 3The business being separated moves to a new company, which issues shares to the shareholders.
Capital reduction demerger. A new holding company is inserted, then reduces its share capital. In return, the business being separated passes to a second new company, which issues its shares to the same shareholders. No distributable reserves are needed and it works for property and investment businesses. Company A after the split Company B after the split New company

FAQs

Frequently asked questions

Why not simply sell the building to a new company?

A sale between companies is normally a taxable disposal. Here the building cost around £200,000 and was worth around £3m, so a gain of around £2.8m would have arisen in the company. At 25%, that is around £700,000 of corporation tax. A transfer of the property to another company would also ordinarily trigger stamp duty land tax (SDLT) on its market value. A properly planned demerger aims to use the reliefs for reorganisations instead.

What did the demerger achieve for this family?

The building was separated from the trading company into a new company owned by the family in the same proportions as the trading company. There was no capital gains tax for the siblings, no corporation tax on the gain in the company and no SDLT on the demerger. We estimate the saving at over £800,000.

Why does SDLT matter so much in a property demerger?

Moving property between companies is normally a land transaction, and SDLT is charged on market value. Being able to move property between companies without an SDLT bill is one of the greatest benefits of a capital reduction demerger, provided the reliefs and clearance are in place first.

What is the base cost point?

It is the part other advisers had missed. We structured the steps so that the property's base cost in the new company reflects its current value of around £3m, not the original £200,000. If the family sold the building tomorrow, there would be no capital gains to pay on the growth to date. The anti-avoidance rules had to be addressed carefully, and they were dealt with in the HMRC clearance application before any step was taken.

Why was HMRC clearance applied for first?

Clearance gives certainty before any irreversible step. We applied for HMRC clearance before anything was implemented, so any questions could be answered, or the plan changed, while it was still only a plan. HMRC must normally reply to a complete statutory clearance application within 30 days.

Why separate the building from the trading company at all?

The family may sell the trading business in future. Keeping the property inside the trading company would complicate that sale and expose the building to trading risk. With the building in its own company, the trading business is cleaner to sell and the building is separate from the risks of trading.

How were the three siblings' different shareholdings handled?

The owners hold 70%, 20% and 10%. The new company was owned in the same proportions as the trading company. The eldest sister, who holds the largest share and manages the family's affairs, holds the voting control, so decisions stay with her while value and growth are shared across the family, including the next generation.

How long did it take?

From instruction to completion took three months, including the HMRC clearances and all the legal implementation. The family had first spoken to us eight months before instructing us, and in that time sorted out practical points such as their mortgage position and a refinance.

What happens next for the family?

The work continues. The family owns other properties, which are being transferred directly into the Family Investment Company. Some have only a small gain, so the SDLT cost on those transfers is manageable. A family trust has also been set up to move value out of the siblings' estates over time.

Free guide

Demergers: the owner's tax guide

The main UK demerger routes, the reliefs and HMRC clearances that make them work, and the order of steps that protects them, for owners and their advisers.

Demergers: the owner's tax guide

Talk to us before anything moves.

In a demerger, the order of the steps is everything. A confidential first call, with a reply the same working day.

Or write to taxadvisory@aswatax.co.uk

Chartered Tax Adviser
Message us on WhatsApp (opens in a new tab)